Get a taste of Columbia as a flavor of ice cream

From sweet tea to peach, here are what ice cream flavors you said best describe our city.

Five ice cream cones and lots of sprinkles.

If the ice cream is strawberry, that means it counts as a serving of fruit — right? Asking for a friend. | Photo via Unsplash

Recently, we asked you to come up with a unique ice cream flavor that describes Columbia and utilizes one to three locally sourced ingredients. After reading all of your responses, it’s safe to say that our mouths are watering. Here were some of our favorites:

Cottle Strawberry Farm ice cream topped with dark chocolate covered pecans from The Peanut Man and diced fresh strawberries. Called “Summer Strawberry Indulgence.” - Becky R.

A sweet tea flavored ice cream topped with sliced strawberries from Cottle Strawberry Farm and fresh basil from the Columbia Farmers Market. Called “Soda City Sunrise.” - Jackson L.

Peach ice cream topped with a hummingbird cupcake from Lita’s Treats. Called “Peach Perfect.” - Lisa L.

A USC women’s basketball-themed ice cream featuring coffee ice cream using coffee from Oliver Gospel Roastery and topped with caramel popcorn bits from Carolina Kernels. Called “Natty Crunch.” - Madelyn S.

Steel Hands Brewing Pecan Brown Ale flavored ice cream with Bell’s Honey, pecan butter toffee from Soda City Candy, and Colombia Tolima coffee from Loveland Coffee. Called “Pregame Puh-KAHN Coffee Toffee.” - Laura R.

Vanilla bean in a ginger cookie bowl that’s topped with diced peaches from McLeod Farms, toasted pecans from Golden Kernel Pecan Company, and drizzled with a syrup made from Cavalier Cream Pecan Praline from Gorget Distillery. Called “Peachy Pecan Rum-ble.” - Kim P.

The only thing we need now is a local ice cream shop to make one of these flavors a reality. Sweet Cream Co., Scoopy Doo Gelato Shop, The Baked Bearwe’re looking at you.

More from COLAtoday
The 16th annual Mardi Gras Columbia Festival features 19 local bands across three stages, plus a parade, food vendors, and craft beer.
Experience Columbia SC introduces its 2026 ambassadors, highlighting locals shaping how visitors experience the Midlands.
Learn about Martin Luther King Jr.'s presence in Columbia and how to commemorate his life and legacy on Martin Luther King Jr. Day.
ColaJazz Foundation and the Koger Center announce seven intimate jazz performances running from February through December.
If you’re trying to reach new running goals, consider signing up for one of these upcoming races or find ways to get more steps in around Columbia
For every Bradford Pear you remove from your property, Clemson and the Forestry Commission will give you a free replacement, but only while supplies last.
Get your calendars out and start booking your reservations at these Midlands eateries offering special dishes, menus, and deals for a limited time during Restaurant Week South Carolina.
We compiled all of the feedback from our Giving Campaign to learn what readers love most and want to see more of in our newsletters. Here’s a peek at what they said.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
Dining in Columbia is always a fresh experience, with new restaurants popping up all the time — and more on the way.