The Sweet ‘N’ Low-down on sweet tea

sweet tea

photo by Pexels

Table of Contents

S.C.’s love affair with sweet tea is indisputable. It’s true – besides its omnipresent status as the house beverage of nearly every restaurant in the region, evidence of our devotion to the sugary refreshment is palpable:

While there are certain cities beyond the Mason-Dixon line that claim to have thrown the original Tea Party (Boston), + others that allege to have invented sweet tea (Chicago), we’re here to set things straight and South Carolina rightfully deserves credit for both. Sort of.

Mason, the World’s Largest Sweet Tea | Image provided by the Town of Summerville

Mason, the World’s Largest Sweet Tea | Image provided by the Town of Summerville

The Charleston Tea Parties

These days, the combination of tea, ice + sugar has become known as the Holy Trinity of the South but we weren’t always such dedicated fans. That’s due to Parliament’s 1773 passage of the Tea Act, which essentially monopolized tea sales in the American colonies – a move which, you guessed it, angered American merchants.

So, on Dec. 3, 1773 13 days before that famous Tea Party in Boston – a group of Charlestonians refused to purchase a shipment of tea that arrived at the Harbor. Instead, they seized it + locked it away in the Exchange building.

But in S.C., they knew how to have their tea + dump it, too. One year later, another ship arrived with imports of tea. This time – it was all dumped into the Cooper River. Sip on that, Parliament.

Will the real inventor of sweet tea please stand up?

Trick question – because sweet tea is best enjoyed sitting down. Preferably on a porch.

Most historians will agree that the first place in the U.S. to achieve long-term tea production was in Summerville, at Dr. Charles Shepard’s Pinehurst Tea Plantation. After that, though, the truth about sweet tea’s origin gets a little murky.

The first-known published sweet tea recipe was in an 1879 cookbook by Marion Cabell Tyree called “Housekeeping in Old Virginia.” However, it calls for green tea, not black.

Then, there’s the popular anecdote claiming iced tea was invented at the 1904 World’s Fair in Chicago. But two things are wrong with this story: 1. It isn’t true, as evidenced partially by the aforementioned recipe, published decades before the event, and 2. Even if it were true, the story does still not account for sweet tea.

Additionally, there really aren’t any historical accounts that explain the exact origin of sweet tea as we know it today: black tea, sweetened while hot + poured over ice.

Can’t turn water into wine? Turn it into sweet tea.

While we don’t know for certain where sweet tea came from (though, for all intents + purposes, we’ll say Summerville), there’s one interesting theory about how it became so popular in the South: Baptists.

Some theorize that, because Southern Baptists are teetotalers (meaning they can’t drink alcohol), they instead tend to indulge in sugary beverages. In other words – since they’re not getting sugar from alcohol consumption – they’re putting it in their tea. Hallelujah, sweet tea!

Best sweet tea in Columbia

Now that enjoying a glass of ice-cold sweet tea is not ancient historywe wanted to know who has your favorite sweet tea in Columbia.

Groucho’s took the #1 spot, but not far behind was Lizard’s Thicket – followed by McAlister’s, Rush’s + Bojangles. And one place that really took us by surprise (because it was said by more than one person): San Jose. To each their own.

Like most Southerners, I used to prefer sweet tea – but after learning more about the dangers of consuming too much sugar (and learning that most servings of sweet tea contain more sugar than the American Heart Association’s recommended daily limit), I decided my calories were better spent elsewhere.

Now, I stick to enjoying a glass of unsweetened, ice tea (which naturally contains caffeine, but zero calories, + no added sugar) with a lemon, or – if I really need a sugary fix – I’ll lessen the blow by ordering a tea that’s half sweet, half unsweet.

Need to let us know about your favorite local glass of sweet tea? Drop us a line on our posts on Instagram, Facebook + Twitter.

–COLAtoday team

More from COLAtoday
Six Columbia organizations receive $280,512 from the Knight Foundation to support arts programming, Finlay Park activation, and civic engagement initiatives.
The Fireflies revive the Capital City Bombers at Segra Park July 10–12 with throwback merch, promotions, and Columbia baseball history.
Birds like the ruby-throated hummingbird will be appearing in Columbia in the spring — find out where you can go to catch a sighting.
South Carolina Ballet’s William Starrett received the Order of the Palmetto during the company’s 65th anniversary performance.
Plan your day at the 44th annual St. Pat’s in Five Points with this quick guide to music, the parade, races, and more.
Columbia arts leader Larry Hembree will receive One Columbia’s 2026 Stephen G. Morrison Visionary Award, honoring decades of cultural leadership.
Nearly 200 free wellness classes — from yoga to Zumba — launch at Finlay Park starting Monday, March 16.
We asked new COLAtoday subscribers their favorite restaurant in the Columbia area. These 10 spots were mentioned the most.
It’s free to attend as the sports network spotlights Greenville and the SEC Women’s Basketball Tournament.
South Carolina opens the SEC Women’s Basketball Tournament on Friday, March 6, in Greenville, with fan deals, downtown events, and the Gamecock Club headquarters.